Research portal · 学术研究

Concepts, claims, and points of dispute

For readers in philosophy, religious studies, ethics, and philosophy of science. No invented academic endorsement—only the system's definitions, arguments, tensions, and versions.

Version 1.0.0Reviewed 2026-07-11Chinese and English reviewed

Two-axis model · 双轴模型

Current does not mean empirical

Doctrinal status answers how the community currently rules; claim type answers what method should evaluate it. Confessional status is an additional marker, not an evidence level.

Doctrinal status

Current Doctrine

The ruling currently operative under the interpretive hierarchy.

Symbolic Narrative

Carries structures of meaning without automatically becoming empirical fact.

Historical Formulation

Preserved as doctrinal history but not the current ruling.

Open Question

No settled current answer; research and deliberation remain open.

Claim type

Empirical

Observation, records, and relevant methods

Historical

Sources, dating, and textual evidence

Logical / conceptual

Definition, consistency, and inference

Metaphysical

Comprehensive interpretation and coherence

Ethical

Experience, dignity, consequence, and responsibility

Experiential

First-person experience and its limits

Symbolic

Meaning-structure and narrative context

Institutional

Rights, procedure, and enforceable rules

Claim index · 命题索引

Twelve located claims

The index is not a new confession; it helps readers trace source and status conflicts.

IDClaimStatus / typeSource
P-01Reality is one; nothing stands outside the One.Current DoctrineMetaphysicalP00087–P00112
P-02Unity does not cancel the reality of persons, difference, boundaries, or suffering.Current DoctrineMetaphysicalP00099–P00112
P-03The seven manifestations are symbolic structure, not seven datable physical events.Symbolic NarrativeSymbolicP00876–P00909
P-04Severance is the finite subject's absolutization of the partial and closure to feedback.Current DoctrineLogical / conceptualP01552–P01764
P-05Salvation is borne by the person but realized in relation and community.Current DoctrineEthicalP02332–P02366
P-06After death, the soul enters disembodied observation.Current DoctrineMetaphysical · ConfessionalP00027–P00043; P03985–P04007
P-07Rejected claimThe Realm of Observation has been empirically established.Historical FormulationEmpirical原典不作此主张 / Not claimed by the canon
P-08Observers have causal-domain knowledge, not cosmic omniscience.Current DoctrineMetaphysical · ConfessionalP04046–P04110
P-09Observers retain some important memories while emotion ceases.Current DoctrineMetaphysical · ConfessionalP00035–P00039; P04133–P04168
P-10The mechanism, timing, and observable model of cosmic convergence remain open.Open QuestionEmpiricalP00040–P00043
P-11The present cosmos will converge and the One will manifest anew.Current DoctrineMetaphysical · ConfessionalP04318–P04428
P-12Civilization turning toward truth is a self-adopted direction, not a guarantee of historical victory.Current DoctrineEthicalP00047–P00048; P04260–P04308

Comparative position · 比较定位

Kinship, difference, and classification

Comparison does not depend on absolute novelty; family resemblance is itself researchable.

Monism

Shares a nondual account of ultimate reality; adds a stronger account of difference, relation, and normative correction.

Process philosophy

Shares priority of becoming and relation; retains ultimate unity and specific eschatological confession.

Naturalistic religion

Shares respect for natural continuity and scientific boundaries; the Realm and renewed manifestation keep it from strict naturalism.

Pantheism

There is genuine family resemblance; distinctiveness must come from doctrinal structure, not naming.

Emergentism

The seven manifestations and the rise of awareness invite dialogue with emergentism without fixing one scientific mechanism.

Compatibilism

Understands freedom as reflective agency within causal conditions, not uncaused choice.

Internal tensions · 内部张力

Texts that resist easy harmony

Current editing follows later, specific, higher-level rulings; isolated conflicts remain visible in the source.

01

Unified cosmic consciousness

P00190's certainty conflicts with the later D-level exploratory status and rules permitting multiple interpretations. The site marks it open.

Open Question
02

Every memory or some important memories

P04125's ‘every sensory fragment’ is overridden by the General Ruling, the chapter's majority formulation, and the confession: some important memories.

Historical Formulation
03

The phrase ‘ghostly substance’

This isolated phrase conflicts with repeated denials of an invisible body. The site uses ‘relational soul becomes personal causal core’ and does not scientize it.

Historical Formulation

Research questions · 研究问题

Directions not yet closed

The list presupposes no assent and does not treat future research as present proof.

  1. 01

    Can embodied consciousness and postmortem soul-continuity form a noncontradictory model of personal identity?

  2. 02

    How can the One as a metaphysical concept avoid explanatory indistinguishability?

  3. 03

    How should the scope, subject, and memory conditions of causal-domain knowledge be defined?

  4. 04

    Should convergence and renewed manifestation remain purely eschatological, or admit evidence-constrained cosmological models?

  5. 05

    How can founder interpretation be constrained by enforceable independent governance?

  6. 06

    How should civilizational continuation order ecological limits, technological risk, and intergenerational justice?

Citation · 引用

Cite this edition and the source

Website summaries do not replace the canon. Scholarly citation should include the DOCX title, paragraph identifier, site version, and access date.

BibTeX ↓RIS ↓Research reading list